Pie Rankings

Pie Review Rankings for all bought pies on Pierate


All pies have been given a score out of 7. Those pies which score 5 out of 7 or more can use our 'Pierate Recommended' Logo. Those pies which score 6 out of 7 or more can use our 'Pierate Highly Recommended' Logo. For more information see our introduction to Pierate recommended pies.


Click here for the Interactive Rankings Page

Where possible, the brand of pie is given. If it is only produced in one establishment, the location is given. All pies were consumed in the UK unless stated otherwise.

Whilst many homemade pies have been given a score out of 7, we felt they should not be listed here due to not being readily available night or day for all our blog readers to purchase and try. However we are indebted to our lovely pie-providing friends across the country. Keep up the great work!

Last updated - 28th July 2017

Click on the pie to go straight to the review for our Top 40 and Bottom 5!

V = Vegetarian, G = Gluten Free


RankPie ProducerPie FlavourScoreByInfo
1
MYPIE LondonSteak and Ale
6.61
R/S
2
MYPIE LondonVenison, Chilli and Cheese
6.57
SJL
3
King's Farm [HP22 6BH]All Steak
6.5
SJL
3
Piebury Corner [N7 8DL]Venison and Red Wine [Thierry Henry]
6.5
RAS
3
Piebury Corner [N7 8DL]Lamb and Veg with a hint of mint [Ian Wright]
6.5
RAS
3
JB Christie [ML6 6BU]Minced Beef Scotch
6.5
SJL
7
MYPIE LondonMince, Bacon and Cheese
6.46
SJL
7
The Real Pie CompanyPork, Bacon and Parsley
6.46
RAS
9
Jekyll and Hyde Pub [B4 6BJ]Steak
6.45
RAS
10
The Pie KitchenChicken, Chantenay Carrot and Bacon
6.43
SJL
10
The Brampton Pie CompanySteak & Ale
6.43
SJL
12
PieministerBeef and Brandy [Kate and Wills]
6.42
TJP
13
Gold Star Bakery [New Zealand]Chicken and Vegetable
6.41
TJP
14
Mother MashSteak and Ale
6.4
TJP
14
Piebury Corner [N7 8DL]Pork, Apple and Stuffing [Ray Parlour]
6.4
RAS
16
MYPIE LondonChicken, Smoked Ham and Tarragon
6.39
RAS
16
Nice Pie [LE14 3NB]Crocodile, Leek and Potato
6.39
SJL
18
Lovett PiesHam Hock, Black Pudding and Pea
6.37
SJL
19
The Hull PieMutton and Ale
6.36
RAS
19
Mother MashChicken, Leek and Ham
6.36
RAS
21
HiggidySteak and Red Wine
6.35
RAS
22
Pleasant House Pub/Royal Pies, USASteak and Ale
6.34
SJL
22
Morecambe Football ClubSteak and Ale
6.34
RAS
24
Piebury Corner [N7 8DL]Venison, Ox Cheek and Mushroom
6.32
RAS
25
Dee's PiesChicken and Chorizo
6.3
RAS
25
Sweeney and Todd [RG1 7RD]Lamb, Pork, Carrot and Potato [Vicar's]
6.3
SJL
27
Molesworths of Henleaze [BS9 4JP]Steak and Gravy
6.29
RAS
28
Pie and Tart Specialists, Hong KongOstrich
6.26
SJL
29
Hoosier Mama Pie Company, USAChicken Pot
6.24
SJL
30
The Real Thai-Pie CompanyThai Red Chicken Curry
6.23
SJL
30
The Real Thai-Pie CompanyDevil Chicken
6.23
SJL
30
Walker and SonPork and Pickle
6.23
SJL
33
Kandy Bar BakeryBeef Scotch
6.21
R/S
33
Kandy Bar BakeryBeef and Onion
6.21
SJL
33
The Real Pie CompanySteak and Horseradish
6.21
RAS
33
Fabulous Fan FayreChicken and Ham
6.21
RAS
33
The Hull PieJerk Chicken and Sweet Pepper
6.21
SJL
33
The Real Pie CompanySteak and Guinness
6.21
RAS
33
The Real Pie CompanySteak and Mushroom
6.21
RAS
33
The Farmers Boy Inn [GL17 0LP]Steak and Stout
6.21
SJL
33
Sweeney and Todd [RG1 7RD]Turkey [Christmas]
6.21
RAS









RankPie ProducerPie FlavourScoreByInfo
622
Hungry Horse Pub [GL3 3TW] Minced Beef [Big Cornish Cow]
1.35
SJL
623
Westside Heritage [B650JN]Steak
1.25
RAS
624
KershawsLuxury Steak
1.20
TJP
625
Firkins"Steak and Ale"
1.00
RAS
625
Delissia"Apple"
1.00
TJP
V


You can now see these pies listed by category or by geographical location on our Pie Treasure Map.

Make sure you 
and let us know your thoughts!