Thursday, 15 May 2014

More Morrisons Pies

Morrisons Pie Counter - Pie Reviews

If you were following our exploits during British Pie Week you might have noticed that I ate Pie for every meal during the week. This was quite a challenge but fortunately I had some help. Morrisons were kind enough to provide a crate of 14 pies on Day Three of the challenge which certainly went some way to helping me decide what pies I should eat for the 21 meals!


I was pretty excited to get this stash of pies. It is well documented on Pierate that Morrisons is the only supermarket with a pie counter and hence we have a special affection for this supermarket chain, have a look at all the Morrisons pie reviews we have done. I will now attempt to review all of these pies in one post, assisted by the video diary I took throughout the challenge.

Have a look at the photo above and I think you will agree that seeing all these pie together is a beautiful sight. They all arrived in good Condition and the Colour of the pastry was varied, but all of them looked appealing. All of the savoury pies had a great Capacity being quite tall, whereas pies at this price tend to be quite shallow.

First up, for dinner on Day Three was a Steak & Ale, see the video below. This was in the standard oval shape that a number of pie counter pies come in. Sadly I would say this was a false start for Morrisons, I didn't find a whole lot of meat Content in the pie but what was there tasted nice and wasn't Chewy. The sauce was flavoursome. The pastry, was crumbly and flour-y as it was for a number of these pies. The pastry lid had some 'overhang' so it missed the optimum pastry to filling ratio. The second pie was better filled than the first so they are lacking in some Consistency. It was £1.70 for two individual pies which is a standard price for these pie counter pies. Considering that a premium pie costs £2 to £3 per pie in a supermarket this puts into perspective that these are not premium pies but 'everyday' pies and I consider this excellent Cheapness for two pies.





Steak & Ale (Morrisons Pie Counter)
4.30/7

Morrisons will be pleased to know that on Day Four I ate Morrisons pies for every meal. See the video below. I started with an Individual Apple pie for breakfast. These were slightly smaller and less tall than the savoury pies, but with a bulging lid they still had an excellent Capacity. The Content was packed with apple which was firm to the bite but not Chewy. The pie was not too sweet and overall fantastic value for just £1.10 for two. I can also confirm they are conistently good as I ate one again for breakfast on Day Five. A very impressive offering here from Morrisons. The only downside again was that there was a surplus pastry overhang, however, in this case the sweet pastry was lovely to eat by itself so this wasn't a problem.

For lunch I had a Cheese & Onion vegetarian pie.  It had a great Capacity although there was a huge air gap which lost it a lot of score. The Content wasn't overpoweringly onion-y or cheesy as I feared it might be, if anything it was too bland. The pastry was the same as with most of the savoury pies. I ate both these pies cold, perhaps heating them up might have helped.


For dinner I really enjoyed the Chunky Steak pie which was much better than the Steak & Ale. There was a lot of meat which was fairly tender. There was a good amount of thick meaty sauce. This was the highest calorie pie, perhaps why it tasted better. Well filled despite an air gap, there was a good pastry to filling ratio.


Individual Apple Pie (Morrisons Pie Counter)
5.65/7

Cheese & Onion (Morrisons Pie Counter)
3.70/7

Chunky Steak (Morrisons Pie Counter)
5.45/7

Day Five saw me desperately trying to review more of these pies before I stretched my relaxed attitude to 'best before' dates a bit too far. As mentioned already I had another apple pie for breakfast before a Steak & Kidney pie for lunch. I ate this cold but really enjoyed it. It was the same oval shape as the Steak & Ale, filled better but still with a sizable air gap. The cold pastry was not dry at all but lovely and crumbly. I could taste the kidney and found some small pieces but I was pleased that the Content did not taste too strongly of kidney. I think the balance of flavours here was just right for me. I ate the other pie hot at a later date and can confirm that they are Consistently good.


Steak & Kidney (Morrisons Pie Counter)
5.10/7

I was unable to eat the Family Apple Pie in British Pie Week because I was only trying to eat whole pies, not slices and it was just too big for me to eat in one go! However, I shared it with my family at a later date and it was again another superb apple pie from Morrisons Pie Counter. The box stated deep filled and it really was with a huge amount of apple content. Firm to the bite, it wasn't too Chewy or too sugary. The pastry had a wonderful sugary glaze meaning it had a superior Crunch and Colour when compared to the individual version. The gooey/crunchy pastry was consistently delicious across both pies. It was also very large for only £2.99, I had some left over when serving four people. It seemed quite similar to the Sainsbury's Taste the Difference premium apple pie but it cost a whole £1 less.

Slice of the Family Sized Apple Pie
Family Apple Pie (Morrisons Pie Counter)
6.05/7

Lastly was the hand-crimped pork pie which I have reviewed before. I can confirm it is still worth the 5.55 out of 7 I gave it last year.

In all I ate Morrisons pies for six meals in a row. What did I learn? That Morrisons Pie Counter pies are great value and I am still in love with the pie counter. I love how the flavours of the pies are printed on the edge of the pie and I love the crumbly pastry most of them have. It seems that many of the savoury pies have quite large air gaps but at this price they still provide a great value pie experience. At Pierate we are looking for pies that we think people should buy and at Morrisons pie counter the pies are cheap enough that the average person can afford to buy them regularly, these really are pies for the people.

Importantly I have also found that it is best to microwave these pies, given that they are already in a cooked state they simply need heating up and this stops them drying out. Or perhaps even forget heating them up at all. Now I realise that these pies work so well cold I think I will be eating them before I get home in the future!

SJL


Pierate is a pie review website charting a course to find the ultimate pie. For all the pies we have reviewed have a look at our Pie Rankings or find pies of a particular flavour under Pies: Categorised.

Make sure you 
and let us know your thoughts!
continue reading "More Morrisons Pies"

Wednesday, 14 May 2014

¡Arriba Arriba Andale Arriba! A Mexican pie from ASDA

mexican beef pie asda
¡Hola! ¿Que paso? Where’s the biblioteca? Now check out this is a Mexican Beef Pie from ASDA. Have a good look, say hello, give it a Mexican wave. This pie promises “Tasty chilli beef with black eyed beans and jalapeno peppers, wrapped in tomato and coriander pastry finished with a tasty monterey jack and tortilla crumb”. Sounds pretty good, right?! They even caught the eye of the member of staff on check-out, who gave them a long (and longing) look. They’re £3 for the pair – so £1.50 per pie. They’re not particularly big, but they certainly don’t sound like your standard pies so £1.50 sounds about right for an own brand frozen pie.
mexican beef pie asda
They take rather a long time in the oven – a whole 50 minutes just for one of these little pies! Wow, not exactly Speedy Gonzales. Still, good things come to those who wait. And that gives you a good 50 minutes to knock back some Cuervo and get in the Mexican mood.

Of course, you might have noticed that this pie doesn’t have a pastry lid – instead ASDA have opted for an unconventional tortilla crumb topping. Technically this does mean it’s not really a pie, but in the words of Senor Chang from Community: “I’ll allow it”.

mexican beef pie asda

Once out of the oven, the pie is a nice golden brown and, aside from a few cracks in the pastry, looks rather good. At this stage I’m hoping the filling is moist, because the rest of the pie looks rather dry. On the cross-section above, you can indeed see that the filling fortunately is moist, as it dribbles out onto plate.

The pie tastes really good. There’s a decent hit of chilli – I’m not a chilli fiend by any means but I also don’t shy away from hot foods, and the hotness of this chilli is just about right for me. The beef is, as expected, minced, but it’s alright and not too chewy. The pie is quite small though and there isn’t a huge amount of filling. However, the filling does fill the capacity of the pie with not too much air gap. I think the pastry is a little dry though, perhaps a symptom of being in the oven for so long.

On the whole, I think this pie is decently priced, tastes good, is innovative and used British beef, but does take a long time to oven cook, is a bit too small, with dry pastry and doesn’t have a pastry lid. I’d recommend this pie, but don’t expect it to be similar to what you’d normally expect from a pie.

ASDA Mexican Beef Pie
Score: 4.95/7
TJP
continue reading "¡Arriba Arriba Andale Arriba! A Mexican pie from ASDA"

How To Rate A Pie - The Pierate Guide

How do you review a pie like a Pierateer? Here's a little infographic we've made on scoring pies using the Seven Cs - it will hopefully have you rating pies in no time! (Click to enlarge)

pie review

continue reading "How To Rate A Pie - The Pierate Guide"

Tuesday, 13 May 2014

Pierateers celebrate 150,000 with BBC Radio appearance!

It seems people love pies! And it seems people love our pie reviews on www.pierate.co.uk! So today we are delighted to be celebrating our 150,000th page view with a special post highlighting our top pie articles so far and an appearance on BBC Local Radio's "Mark Forrest Show"!


Pierate Pie Review Pageviews

November 2009 – The Pierate Ship sets sail
January 2012 – We celebrated 10,000 pageviews
July 2012 – We reached 15,000 pageviews
March 2013 – We landed on 25,000 pageviews
October 2013 – We hit 50,000 pageviews
February 2014 – We were delighted to make 100,000 pageviews
May 2014 – We are amazed to reach 150,000 pageviews



But wait – there’s more! As it happened, one of the big topics on the BBC Local Radio summary show – the “Mark Forrest Show” – was pies and unusual pie fillings! So no sur-pies that they called on the pie experts the Pierateers and we had a 10 minute conversation with Mark. It was very flattening to hear Mark say "The strength and depth of this blog is something to inspire" and "It's an amazing blog." While sadly the recording was only online for one week, you can read some of the articles we referred to below.



And without further ado, here are our top 5 articles from our first 150,000 pageviews:

1) Best Pies in London Restaurants – 1,585
2) Best Pie in London – 1,516
3) Is it a pie? McDonalds under the knife – 1,426
4) Pierate in the Urban Dictionary - 679
5) What Makes The Best Scotch Pie? - 525


Plus with over 8,000 pageviews already, it’s no surprise our Pierate Pie Rankings page is the most visited page on Pierate!

Thanks once again to all the pie fans out there who make writing all these pie reviews such a PIEleasure! Enjoy!


Pierate is a pie review website charting a course to find the ultimate pie. For all the pies we have reviewed have a look at our Pie Rankings or find pies of a particular flavour under Pies: Categorised.

Make sure you 
and let us know your thoughts!
continue reading "Pierateers celebrate 150,000 with BBC Radio appearance!"

Friday, 9 May 2014

Reci-pie Review: Oh My Pecan Pie!



One of the great things about being a pie addict is that you sometimes get given pie-related presents. For Christmas this year one of my friends wrapped up a massive tin of proper Canadian maple syrup for me, which came complete with a recipe for maple pecan pie on the top!

As delicious as the recipe looked, there was a big problem with it – it didn’t have a lid. As regular readers of pierate.co.uk will know, a pie with a lid is, in fact, not a pie at all, so I had to modify the recipe a bit. However as this is probably the sweetest, gooiest pie I’ve ever eaten I was glad of some extra pasty to add a bit of crunch.

The recipe:
I’m not sure how well you can see the recipe in the photo, but it calls for a nine inch pie crust, so the first thing you’ll need to do is make a batch of shortcrust pastry, roll it out and cook it in a pie dish. If you’re a pie purist like me, make sure you also bake a lid (I went for a lattice top). You cook the filling for this pie separately rather than in the pastry, so you’ll need to add your lid on at the end.

After that the recipe is simple – just make sure you have some measuring cups handy:

Pour 1 ¼ cups of maple syrup and ¾ cup of water into a pan and bring the mixture to the boil. Then mix 4 tbsp cornflour and 2 tbsp water together and add it to the boiling syrupy mixture. Keep mixing and eventually the mixture will turn dark brown, thick and shiny. 

One the mixture has thickened up, take it off the heat and stir in a knob of butter. Then leave it to cool for about five minutes before pouring the syrup mixture and a large handful of pecans into the pie crust.
 Finally, once the mixture has cooled a little bit, add your lattice lid to make it a proper pie.

The Seven Cs:

Colour:
The colour of this pie is down to you, so be brave and leave the pastry case and lid in the oven until they’re a nice golden brown. You also need to keep cooking the maple syrup and cornflour mixture until it turns a really dark, shiny brown. Do both of these things and this pie will score top marks for colour.

Consistency:
This pie has the most ridiculously wobbly, gooey, sweet, sugary consistency of any pie I have ever eaten, with lovey chewy, crunchy pecans. I absolutely loved it and couldn’t stop scoffing it with vanilla ice cream and cups of tea – but if you don’t like sickly gooey things then this definitely isn’t for you.

Capacity:
The original recipe lost some points when it came to capacity because it didn’t have a lid – however once I’d rectified that small problem I found that there was a perfect crust:filling ratio. You definitely need the extra pastry on top of this pie to cut through the aforementioned gooiness. 

Chewiness:

Apart from the pecans, there isn’t much chewiness going on in this pie. Just yummy, gooey, sugary goodness. Mmmmm.

Cheapness:
Proper maple syrup (rather than the maple-flavoured but not-actually-maple syrup you can also get) isn’t the cheapest ingredient you’re going to find in your cupboard, but it’s not too bad considering you can use the leftovers in all manner of delicious baked goods. Even better, the rest of the ingredients in this recipe are really cheap and this pie looks, smells and tastes amazing, so it’s definitely worth the cost of the syrup.

Content:
Pecan pie is a bit of a novelty in the UK, as we tend to think of it as being a Canadian/American classic, so I think this wins points for having an interesting flavour. The texture of this pie is also very different to anything I’ve ever eaten – a bit like a treacle tart only without the breadcrumbs. I’m trying not to use the word gooey again but there’s really no other way to describe it. 

Condition:
As long as you cook the filling for long enough, this pie will have golden pastry and a shiny, set-but-still-soft filling, giving it a very high score for condition. It also smells amazing and you’ll struggle to get your nose out of it for long enough to actually eat some. 

The Ship's Cook

continue reading "Reci-pie Review: Oh My Pecan Pie!"

Thursday, 8 May 2014

YouTube number boffin calculates Pi using...pies

Matheon2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Matheon2.jpg

A YouTube video blogger has quite accurately calculated the value of pi using nothing but chalk, a calculator and a LOT of pies.



Boffin blogger Numberphile used pies to calculate pi to be 3.13834 - pretty close to pi's actual value of 3.14159(...). Is this how Archimedes calculated pi?

Although if you want to see a really impressive use of pi, here's 10,000 digits of pi, sent to us by 'Tesco Kaz'!

Pi Pie Review
Pi Pie Review
continue reading "YouTube number boffin calculates Pi using...pies"

Wednesday, 7 May 2014

Petition to make it a crime to serve a top-crust pie

Question: Is this a pie?




While many people might say "Yes, this is clearly a pie", there will undoubtedly be a very vocal faction who bellow "NO! This is a CASSEROLE with a pastry lid!". 

Indeed, that is the stance we take at Pierate (and also, incidentally, taken at the British Pie Awards, who disqualify any pie not totally and wholly encased in pastry). We have waged a long battle against pastry-topped pies at Pierate for many years, but it's recently been brought to our attention that there is now a petition gathering signatures to make it a criminal offence to 'wrongly-describe' a pastry-topped pie as a "pie". The petition claims that:
"For too long customers in pubs and restaurants have ordered what is described on the menu as a pie only to be served with casserole in a pot covered by a puff pastry lid. This is not a pie and is also curiously difficult to consume. A pie is defined by the OED as "A baked dish of fruit, or meat and vegetables, typically with a top and base of pastry." epetitions
Indeed, we have felt the sheer disappointment one feels when the menu promises a "pie" yet from the kitchen emerges a pie dish topped off with a disc of pastry. But while we're pretty fanatical about insisting that pies should be wholly encased in pastry, the last part of the petition had even our jaws dropping to the floor.
"This petition urges the implementation of criminal sanctions upon the owners of food outlets that serve items described as pies without a pastry base." epetitions
Blimey! Criminal sanctions! That's pretty severe. I personally wouldn't go that far, but I do think that pubs and restaurants shouldn't be able to get away with falsely serving top-crust pseudo-pies for much longer. What do you think? Do you think the heinous act of wrongfully calling a pastry-topped pie a pie deserve time behind bars? Or should we just get over it? Leave a comment below, and take part in our little poll at the bottom on the right hand side of the page.

With 504 signatures, the petition only needs another 99,496 before the matter could be debated in the House of Commons. The petition was set up by a "Bill T Wulf" - we have no idea who he is, but we'd love to contact him if possible.

(Edit: We found the national hero who set it up)

continue reading "Petition to make it a crime to serve a top-crust pie"

A Big Post About Heinz Big Pies

If you’ve kept your eyes on the pies, you might have noticed a new competitor enter the pie supermarket-place. Manufactured under the Heinz brand, these ‘Big Pies’ from Peters Pies are aiming to take a slice of the £1 price-point pie. But are these pies late on entering an already crowded marketplace?

I popped down to the local ASDA to get my hands on three of these pies. Priced at £1, that certainly sounds like great value for something that so readily promises to be “Big on Flavour”. These three pies are “Steak and Vegetable”, “Chicken and Leek”, and “Steak and Onion”.

Heinz big pie

Heinz big pie

Heinz big pie

We note that the Heinz “Big” brand (including soups, frozen meals and canned meals) is aimed primarily at the male market, thus these Big Pies will be a competitor to the male-orientated Hungry Joes pies we reviewed previously. Furthermore, Wales-based Peters Pies already produce a number of other similar pies already reviewed on Pierate. But clearly Heinz and Peters believe there is still a gap in the market to exploit – and let’s face it, who doesn’t want more pie?!

*Note that four different flavours of Heinz Big Pasties were also launched alongside these pies, but we have a strong (some say irrational) dislike for pasties on Pierate!*

So how to they rate on the Seven Cs?

First up is the Heinz Big Steak and Vegetable Pie

Heinz big pie

Out of the oven, this pie looks pretty standard. I’ve seen many a pie look exactly like this. Golden brown puff pastry lid, with paler, slightly-too-soft sides. There’s an attempt with crimping, but nothing particularly exciting. There’s no boil-out which is good, and also no cracks, so the condition of this pie is okay. Overall, the appearance of this pie is satisfactory but nothing very special.

Notably, though, this pie is not as big as one might expect for a Big pie. It is actually surprisingly small, and I pray that it is stuffed full of content otherwise I might be left still a bit hungry.

Heinz big pie

Hmm, no, it’s not really stuffed full of content. I’d say that’s about half-full, which in our books is a poor air:filling ratio. I am quite disappointed with that. Furthermore, the filling seems to be quite lacking in the “vegetable” promised by the name. There was a bit more vegetable than the solitary pea seen the photograph – but only a little bit more. The chunks of steak and wholesome vegetables certainly weren’t rolling out of the filling like the photograph would suggest.

The filling did taste quite nice – quite soupy. The steak was okay – not too chewy, and for the £1 price tag I was reasonably impressed. But what this pie really lacked was quantity of filling. I worry that Heinz/Peter’s have gone down this “Big” branding route, implying that these pies are for satisfying big appetites, but consumers will ultimately be left disappointed by the lack of “Big”ness.

Heinz Big Steak and Vegetable Pie
Score: 4.4/7

Heinz Big Chicken and Leek Pie

Heinz big pie

Like the steak and vegetable pie, this is a very classic look for a cheap supermarket pie – light golden brown puff pastry with pale sides.

Heinz big pie

Oh my, look at that enormous air gap at the top of this pie. That’s got to be less than 1/2 filling, right? More like 1/3? This is rather disappointing, especially given the photograph on the packet.

imageimage

I wonder why on earth the pastry looks so different in my pie to the photograph. There seems to be a secondary layer of the puff pastry that has slipped down like a veil over the filling (which is remarkably not rolling attractively out of the pie as in the picture). Don’t you think the pastry on the box looks more like shortcrust that puff pastry?! Interesting.

Nevertheless, we soldier on. The filling is actually very pleasant. There is a nice taste of the leek, and the chicken chunks seem genuine and tasty. I like the filling – more so than the steak and vegetable, actually. The pastry, however, is pretty terrible in my opinion – it looks bad and tastes bland.

Heinz Big Chicken and Leek Pie
Score: 4.6/7

Heinz Big Steak and Onion Pie

Heinz big pie

We’re nearing the end of our romp through this Heinz/Peters pie selection, as now we come on to our final pie – the Steak and Onion. It looks very much like the previous two pies. Nothing huge to complain about – very plain. I’m having my pie with some peas, because you have to eat your greens when you’re eating so many pies! (Although SJL did do some science recently to show that eating a pie for every meal for a week can mean you lose weight!)

Heinz big pie

Again, this pie is rather underfilled, although not quite so badly as the other two – plus this pie doesn’t have the odd ‘pastry-veil’ hanging down like the chicken pie. I didn’t like the filling in this pie quite as much, though, and the steak seemed a little chewy to me. Again, I thought the pastry was bland and added little to the party, and the big chunks of potato seemed to be there just to take the place of steak rather than bringing anything to the table themselves. This isn’t really a pie I’d be desperate to put in my fridge/oven/mouth again, although it was by no means terrible. If I had some small change in my pocket and wanted a pie, and this was all that was available, then I’d go for it. Otherwise, I believe the other two Big pie options would be preferable.

Heinz Big Steak and Onion Pie
Score: 4.3/7

So overall, I felt these pies were cheap (great!) but underfilled and lacking in big appetite-bustingness, and with the exception of the chicken and leek they were a rather uninspiring entry into an already busy supermarket pie market.

Those scores again:

Heinz Big Steak and Vegetable Pie
Score: 4.4/7

Heinz Big Chicken and Leek Pie
Score: 4.6/7

Heinz Big Steak and Onion Pie
Score: 4.3/7
TJP
continue reading "A Big Post About Heinz Big Pies"

Tuesday, 6 May 2014

British Pie Awards 2014

British Pie Awards 2014 - Church
The home of the British Pie Awards

With over 800 pies from across Britain being judged by over 100 judges, it’s no wonder the British Pie Awards are firmly etched in our pie calendar. Held in St Mary’s Church in the heart of Melton Mowbray, it is a spectacular setting in the home of the pork pie. It may therefore surprise you that this was our debut judging at the British Pie Awards, having been volunteer helpers at the awards in 2013.


Overall there were 19 classes of pies – ranging from small pie producers to the country’s largest pie-makers. But only one of the 825 entries could be named Supreme Champion 2014 and that accolade went to Graham Aimson, Jackie Simpson and the Morecambe Football Club Kitchen. Their Bramley Apple pie won the title and we were not at all surprised, as we had thoroughly enjoyed this pie in January. In fact, it received “Pierate Highly Recommended” status with 6.11/7! To top it all off, Graham also won top football pie for his Chicken, Ham and Leek pie which – you guessed it! – we had also rated highly during our visit with a 6.16/7!

British Pie Awards 2014
Supreme Pie Champion at the British Pie Awards 2014
Morecambe Football Club Kitchen

This isn't the first time we've attended the British Pie Awards! Oh no! Find out more in our other articles here:
Judges in 2015  |  Judges in 2014  |  Helpers in 2013



Nice Pie Review
Nice Pie entry into the "Pie Fit for a Hero" Class
As mentioned in our preview article, this year's speciality class, A Pie Fit For A Hero, recognised those providing food for Britain's Armed Services in the centenary year of the start of the First World War. There were some specially decorated entries for this class, including a fabulously decorated pie from Nice Pie (see photo) and the winning entry went to Boghall Butchers, who had a cracking day winning in a number of categories. In our interview with Andy Bates before the pie judging began, he said the key to a good pie was “love and attention” – something which was clearly put into the top pies he judged in the “Pie Fit For a Hero” class.

Other big winners come the pie awards lunch included Nice Pie, who won the Special Award for small pie producers. They may have only been producing pies for about a year but you won’t have failed to notice the impact of Nice Pie on our pie rankings, having not only some of the top rated pies but also some of the most unusual flavours! In fact they make up quite a large proportion of our “Most unusual Pies” article!

Several other producers got top three entries in several categories, including Walker and Sons (who pretty much swept up in the Pork Pie categories and are highly rated by us too), The Outdoor Pig Company and the Great North Pie Company. The Pie Kitchen – who were Supreme Champions in 2013 and were rated highly by us last year – also won in the Beef and any flavour combination category. You can see a list of all the top 3 winners in each category in the British Pie Awards here. It’s certainly left us with plenty of pies to keep our eyes on this coming year!

Pierateer Tim took upon himself the important task of rating the nation’s pies according to the specific British Pie Awards grading criteria, which mark pies out of 100 and award gold, silver and bronze awards to the top pies. While the grading criteria does have some significant differences to the Seven Cs upon which we pie rate ourselves, Tim (who can be seen in the grey top on the Independent’s British Pie Awards article) quickly set to work on the cold pork pies class (class 2) after a judges briefing from head judge Ian Nelson and then a class briefing from Cliff Congrave.

Each pie is judged by two judges, to enable discussion between the pair over the merits of each pie and give a more rounded analysis. Working alongside Sue Woodall, Pierateer Tim judged 16 pork pies before the top pies from the class were reconsidered in a head to head to award a top 3. The winner of class 2 was only then revealed on Thursday at the awards lunch as The Outdoor Pig Company, so many congratulations to them!

British Pie Awards 2014
Pie Judges at the British Pie Awards 2014
There was a vast array of top judges at the awards itself and some classic quotes from the day. They included “There’s few things as bad as undercooked pastry” – something we as Pierateers wholeheartedly agree with when on the Seven Cs of pie rating – and one pie was described as “like roast dinner in a pie!” Pies in the "Other meats" class included squirrel, duck, venison and rabbit, while there were also pies containing beetroot and other interesting ingredients!

In our interview with Head Judge Ian Nelson, from Hovis Ltd, he was “looking to see the consistency and quality of the products across a wide range of the 19 categories”. He was “looking forward to finding the British Pie Champion” and had previously judged at the Scotch Pie Championships (which Pierateer SJL has previously judged at).

Before the pie judging began, the pies were blessed by Reverend Kevin Ashby. Speaking to the Reverend, whose church the awards are held in, he remarked that it was great to see the church used for different events. The church was part of the community in Melton Mowbray and it was great a national event was taking place there. In his fourth year of judging, Reverend Ashby was a particular fan of steak and kidney pies.

British Pie Awards 2014 George Eustice MP
Food Minister George Eustice MP does a bit of pie rating
Throughout the day many people, young and old, visited the church to see pie rating in action, including a special visit from Food Minister George Eustice MP. Speaking to us George commented that while it was the first time he had visited the British Pie Awards, it was a fantastic event in the home of the pork pie. He referred to pies as “the most British of foods” and later had a go at pie rating himself with a selection of pork pies.

In summing up the event, MMPPA chairman Matthew O'Callaghan said: "The competition was tougher than ever this year which makes Morecambe FC’s achievement all the more impressive. It was fantastic to bring together so many people and producers with a passion for pies, quality ingredients and great British food. Praise must go to our judges, who rose to the challenge of tasting and scoring every pie fairly and were extremely impressed by the quality of entries.”

So with the reign of The Pie Kitchen coming to an end, rest assured that pie making is in very good hands in 2014. Having already won in 2011, the Morecambe FC Kitchen have done a fantastic job in winning back their Supreme Champion title and we very much look forward to sampling more of the British Pie Awards 2014 winners in the coming months ahead.

Just remember: pie rating is for life, not just the BPAs! ;-)


RAS

Two fellow judges at the British Pie Awards and friends of Pierate are Nik Speller and Matthew Rippon. You can read their views on the British Pie Awards 2014 on their blogs, with Nik (@NikSpeller) writing on Conrad's Beer and Matthew (@FoodGeography) writing on Food and Geography.

The Pierateers are on a mission to find the best pie they can and you can see a list of their pies rated so far in the Pierate Pie Rankings or find pies of a similar flavour on the Pies: Categorised page.

Make sure you 
and let us know your thoughts!
continue reading "British Pie Awards 2014"

Sunday, 4 May 2014

Dickinson and Morris – More than just Pork Pies

Dickinson and Morris Creamy Chicken Pie Review


When you think Melton Mowbray, you think pork pies. And a fine example of pork pies in the town are from Dickinson and Morris, which we have already highly rated. But while being in Melton Mowbray to attend the British Pie Awards 2014 – where Pierateer TJP was one of the judges – the Pierateers couldn’t help but look for pies to eat and rate after the proceedings had finished. Entering Ye Olde Pork Pie Shoppe, they found alongside the pork pies some meat pies and purchased a creamy chicken pie.

The Dickinson and Morris pork pies got a cracking 6.14/7 (Pierate Highly Recommended) when we rated them! Check out the review of their Mini Melton Mowbray Pork Pies.


Dickinson and Morris Creamy Chicken Pie Review
Dickinson and Morris Creamy Chicken Pie Review

The pie is sold as containing tender pieces of chicken breast in a rich creamy sauce with onion, encased in shortcrust pastry. As you can see from the photo the pastry colour is quite nice and golden, though slightly uneven in shade. The top pastry was a little too crisp around the edge crimping but in general was a nice texture which was firm enough to hold in the filling. The content was nice tender chicken meat and the sauce was lovely and creamy. There was a good quantity of creamy filling to give nice flavour to the meat, helping to balance out the slightly dry outer pastry and thus making it a nice pie to enjoy.

Dickinson and Morris Creamy Chicken Pie Review
Dickinson and Morris Creamy Chicken Pie Review

At £2.15 each, this is quite reasonable for a meaty chicken pie of this size, though I would have liked a slightly better capacity of meat to balance out the slightly pastry-heavy pastry:filling ratio. However all things considered this was a very nice Pierate Recommended pie and considering their main focus is pork pies, I’d certainly commend Dickinson and Morris for being much more than just pork pies!

Dickinson and Morris Creamy Chicken Pie
Score: 5.61/7
[Colour 5.5, Capacity 5.5, Consistency 5.5, Condition 5.5, Chewiness 6, Cheapness 5.5, Content 5.75, Total: 5.61/7]
RAS


See where this pie ended up in the Pierate Pie Rankings or find other pies of a similar flavour.

Make sure you 
and let us know your thoughts!
continue reading "Dickinson and Morris – More than just Pork Pies"

Sunday, 27 April 2014

Which punderful pie will reign supreme at the British Pie Awards 2014?

We are now just days away from the sixth British Pie Awards and the comPIEtition couldn’t be stronger. There will be 825 entries judged under 19 classes – ranging from small pie producers to the country’s largest pie-makers. But only one can be named Supreme Champion 2014!



british pie awards
L-R: Mark Beeston, Matthew O’Callaghan & Stephen Hallam of Melton Mowbray Pork Pie Association - organisers of the British Pie Awards 2014.

Pierateers from the web’s leading pie review website – www.pierate.co.uk – will of course be there judging the pies and doing plenty of tweeting in the lead up to the British Pie Awards 2014 (#bpa14). You also won’t be surPIEsed to find out we’ll have tweet by tweet analysis from the British Pie Awards itself (like in 2013) with Pierateer RAS there as a helper and media on Wednesday 30th April, and we will report on the awards post event and awards lunch, announcing the winning pies!

Of course pie rating is a very serious responsibility – which you will see when reading the hundreds of pie reviews on our pie blog. But you will also notice that we like a bit of pun and games too, which we will also be encouraging at the awards through supplying a suggested pie puns card for judges to crack out during proceedings as they see fit. After all, pies are to be enjoyed and celebrated, providing insPIEration and hopefully PIEfection.

The Pie Awards themselves will have 19 classes that recognise British classics including Beef and Ale Pies, Chicken Pies, Steak and Kidney Pies, Pork Pies and, of course, Melton Mowbray Pork Pies. Pasties, pub pies and football pies will also be honoured, along with dessert pies, vegetarian pies and a savoury pie category. This year's speciality class, A Pie Fit For A Hero, recognises those providing food for Britain's Armed Services in the centenary year of the start of the First World War.

You’ll find that the Pierateers have rated lots of different categories of pies – including those covered by the British Pie Awards – by visiting our Pies: Categorised page.

MMPPA chairman Matthew O'Callaghan said: "Britain is rightly proud of its pies and the British Pie Awards are a celebration of pie producers and bakers, putting their craft in the spotlight. Since the launch of the awards six years ago, the event has grown both in size and in stature. With high-calibre entrants and a wide range of expert judges the awards are recognised as a true mark of quality within the industry and among the public.”

Of course those of you who are regulars on the web’s leading pie reviewing website Pierate already know that Pierateer Tim will be one of those expert pie judges, having rated hundreds of pies that you can see in our pie rankings table.

The panel of 110 judges, which includes food writers, master bakers, chefs and restaurateurs, is led by chairman of the judges Ian Nelson, of Hovis Ltd. He said: "It is a real honour to be heading up the judging panel at the British Pie Awards, an event I have always supported as an opportunity for bakers and pie-makers - and British food - to shine. The task ahead of us is huge with so many entries to be tasted and judged today in 19 different categories but we are all ready for the challenge and excited to be sampling the best pies the nation has to offer."

Joining the judging panel is TV chef and street food afficionado Andy Bates, aka the Pie Man, and he said: “My passion is for great British food and the pie is the perfect way to enjoy quality ingredients and brilliant cooking, whether it’s a traditional recipe or ones with an inspired new twist. I’ve been really looking forward to getting my teeth into picking the best pies from across Britain and am delighted to be in the company of so many top pie producers and knowledgeable judges.”

You won’t be surprised to know we’ve rated a pie made by judge Andy Bates – founder of Eat My Pies – which is the number one hit when you google “Eat My Pies Pie Review” – and we hope to enjoy more in the future.

And having enjoyed and highly rated the Supreme Champion 2013, we are looking forward to seeing who takes the title at the British Pie Awards 2014! May the best pie win!!!


For a flavour of what the British Pie Awards are like, here's a video we made of the event last year, including the epic pie hymn!


RAS
continue reading "Which punderful pie will reign supreme at the British Pie Awards 2014?"

Thursday, 24 April 2014

Best Manze?

M. Manze - Traditional Pie and Mash Shop Review

As part of the my challenge to eat pie for every meal in British Pie Week (see all 21 pies in the summary article) I paid a trip to a very special pie shop in London. This was the M. Manze pie and mash shop on Tower Bridge Road, the oldest surviving pie and mash shop in the country. It opened in 1892. This certainly was a traditional London Pie and Mash Shop, serving pies in the traditional way with a parsley 'liquor' alongside the minced beef pies. See our article on Pie & Mash Shops to find out what makes these places so unique.


The visit was at lunch time on Day One of the challenge. Watch the video below from 3:28 to see the review in action and, among other things, an interview with Matthew Rippon who gave his opinion on the importance of preserving such establishments. Matthew also interviewed Pierateers SJL and RAS in M. Manze which can be heard on his blog.


Firstly, apologies for incorrectly stating that the liqour was made with eel stock, M. Manze have informed us that they no longer do this as it ensures that the liquor can also be eaten with their vegetarian pies (although some places do still use eel stock).

But what did I think? This pie slipped down very well despite the fact that I wasn't really hungry, I always think this is a good sign. There was barely a need to Chew with the pie at all. I don't think I enjoyed it in it's optimal Condition because I let the pie get cold with all the filming but still it was very well presented in the traditional manner and a great contrast of Colours. The pie was nice and soft with the classic puff pastry found at these pie and mash shops. The Capacity was small, as is always the case with these oval shaped pies, however, it was packed with meaty Content with a great beef stock, making giving the pie a satisfying meaty flavour. The liquor was great, not at all suffering from dry parsley syndrome as the Goddard's sauce I had recently did. Overall there was perhaps not as much seasoning with this meal as there was with the recent Eel House Pies, I would have liked more. What was a real winner for this pie was the outstanding value. These traditional pies are normally cheaper than more gourmet alternatives but M. Manze was Cheap even for pie and mash at just £3.50. This is despite being walking distance from Borough Market.


The original features and historic importance make the journey to M. Manze worth it alone. Add to that a very good value pie meal and M. Manze is worth a visit for anyone who loves Pies or History and an absolute must if you share my interest in both! The Manze family are very important to the London Pie and Mash scene. M. Manze have three shops, and another branch of the Manze family created L. Manze in Walthamstow which we have also visited. But who is the Best Manze? It is hard to say given that I visited L. Manze so long ago, I have eaten so many good pies since then, I think I will need to visit both again before I can say categorically! In any case this means that there are now two Manze restaurants on our best pies in London list. There is also Manze in Deptford that I am yet to visit. It is all just an excuse to eat more pie...

Many thanks to M. Manze for being such good hosts and letting us set up camp there for so long!

Traditional Minced Beef (M. Manze)
5.16/7

SJL




Pierate is a pie review website charting a course to find the ultimate pie. For all the pies we have reviewed have a look at our Pie Rankings or find pies of a particular flavour under Pies: Categorised.

Make sure you 
and let us know your thoughts!
continue reading "Best Manze?"